So here’s the question:
Would you be more motivated to do something if you knew you’d get a reward for doing it — or if you knew you’d get punished for not doing it?
Let’s make it even easier.
In my living room, there are 2 chairs and 1 sofa. Every time you come over, I give you $1,000 when you sit in one of the chairs. But if you sit on the sofa, you get a small-but-not-pleasant electric shock.
Obviously, you’d avoid the sofa. But I wonder: How often would you want to come over to my house?
Now, if you knew you’d get $1,000 every time you sat in one of my chairs, wouldn’t you be very enthusiastic about coming over — and even more psyched about sitting in a chair?
I’m not suggesting anything new.
This is positive reinforcement, and I’m reading a terrific book by the original dog whisperer, Paul Owens. In fact, that’s what his book is called: The Dog Whisperer: A Compassionate, Nonviolent Approach to Dog Training.
Believe me, I’m not taking any holier-than-thou attitude. I’ve done many things I’m not proud of in the name of dog training.
My labradoodle and I are still a work in progress — but we are getting there. Slowly but surely, we are getting there.
I’ve mentioned here often enough the struggles I’ve had with Maddie to get her to walk by another dog. Barking, lunging, pulling, yanking … you’d think it would be getting old since she’s already past her 5th birthday.
Our training of each other has taken us from me shouting at her, bumping her with my knee, demanding she sit … even walking totally away from the other dog in a direction I don’t want to go — just to get away from it and avoid having my arm yanked out of my shoulder.
Lately, I’ve been arming myself with freeze-dried chicken. Yes, I hate the idea of buying chicken for either of us to eat.
But it’s harder to stand by your ethical beliefs when you’re desperate — and being physically injured on a daily basis. (Two broken fingers, to name a few of the injuries inadvertently caused by my dog.)
So I’ve been luring her with the chicken these past few weeks. Another dog approaches, I reach into my pocket and let her grab it and chew on it as we make our way past him.
It’s been working. She’s definitely more interested in the chicken than in barking and lunging at another dog.
Fast forward to this morning. I decide to put Owens’ principles of positive reinforcement to work.
Instead of encouraging Maddie to ignore other dogs — in other words, abstain from the “bad” behavior of barking and lunging — I am going to reward her for engaging in a more acceptable behavior of my choosing: Being quiet.
Simply put: Instead of telling Maddie “no” to barking, I am telling her “yes” to being quiet.
It may seem like I’m splitting hairs. But if you think about it, there’s a world of difference.
Our new vocabulary word will be “Quiet.” I will use it when she’s barking and even when she’s about to bark, something I can pretty much anticipate at this point by her forward stance and focused gaze.
I saw the first dog coming not long after we got into the park.
I exhaled big time. (Interestingly, Owens says he always begins group training classes with having the humans do some deep breathing. Calm the human, calm the dog. I know it works, because I’ve done it. It was very nice having my own theory affirmed.)
The other dog gets closer and stares at Maddie (I swear, sometimes I think they’re onto her and are daring her to overreact.)
He’s walking toward us on the path and I see Maddie start to fixate, leaning forward and glaring at the dog.
Exhale again. I grab a piece of chicken from my pocket.
Maddie makes a mild growl in her throat — always the precursor to barking.
“Quiet!” I say firmly.
She looks up at me. “Quiet? What the hell does that mean?”
I hold the piece of chicken near her nose.
The dog gets closer — he’s now maybe 5 feet from us — and Maddie whips her head to look at him.
“Quiet,” I say again in a low, calm voice, keeping the chicken near her nose.
She leans forward to grab some of the chicken in her teeth. I hold onto one end while she nibbles at the other.
The other dog walks past, completely disinterested now in a labradoodle who’s clearly not interested in him!
We move along the path.
Deep exhale.
Bring on the next dog!
Don’t forget to follow me on Twitter!